Apple urged to raise prices to help Chinese workers

by Simon Aughton on October 12, 2010

Apple’s main manufacturer in China has again been criticised for the it they treats its workers. Two new reports claim wages at Foxconn are still too low and one urges Apple to raise prices to support higher salaries.

Foxconn, which is owned by Taiwan’s Hon Hai and also makes products for Dell and HP, first came under scrutiny earlier this year following 13 suicides at their China plants — suicides that labour activists said were triggered by the Taiwan firm’s tough practices and murky corporate culture.

Since the suicides, Hon Hai pledged to improve the livelihood of its 937,000 or so workers in China by raising wages, cutting overtime and building new factories in inland China to allow migrant workers to be closer to home.

But two new reports say the workload is still unrelenting.

One, based on interviews with over 1,700 workers by 20 universities in Hong Kong, China and Taiwan, criticised Hon Hai for long working hours, a “militaristic” work culture and mass employment of low-wage vocational college students and interns on production lines to cut costs.

Foxconn dismissed the report’s “unsubstantiated allegations” and said it treated and paid its workers well.

“Foxconn Technology Group strongly and categorically rejects reports in the Chinese and international media that are attributed to research by academics and students alleging worker abuse, illegal labour practices, and unsafe working conditions at our operations in China.”

A second report by rights group Students and Scholars Against Corporate Misbehavior (SACOM) said many staff were still paid barely more than minimum wage levels in some factories despite promises to beef up basic wages to around 2,000 yuan by October.

Both reports said Hon Hai was hiring young students and interns on a vast scale at low wages to mitigate soaring costs that have eroded profits and hurt its share price this year.

Hon Hai denied this, saying that only around 7.6% of its workforce were interns and that those working overtime had done so voluntarily. It said it was working hard to ban such overtime work by interns.

“Foxconn is certainly not perfect, but we take our responsibility to our employees very seriously,” it said.

Major electronics brands like Apple were also blamed for driving Chinese workers and factory owners to the brink.

“Apple and other brands must raise the unit price of their orders to allow manufacturers to survive while providing a living wage for the workers who produce their electronics products,” wrote SACOM in its report.

Apple declined to comment.

Reuters

For more breaking news and reviews, subscribe to MacUser magazine. We'll give you three issues for £1
  • jimkahnw

    Maybe Apple should be satisfied with lower profits, while boosting the wages of workers who help make it a premier technology company? Why should the customer pay? Clearly, corporate mentality needs to change; business needs to be encouraged to understand how their decisions effect the entire community, not just the bottom line. Too many companies loose site of how they got there. Capitalism needs a conscious.

  • pofadda

    jimkahnw, you are obviously a SOCIALIST!!! These people have been downtrodden by their betters for thousands of years and have surely become used to it. Anyway, they wouldn’t work of they had full bellies, dammit.

  • EdgeCarver

    Maybe Dell and HP should boost the wages of these workers. They, after all, are high volume sellers as distinct from Apple which is a high value seller. And it is volume which affects the amount of overtime that workers endure, not the value of the end-product.

    Moreover, according to this report there were 13 suicides committed in this firm out of 937,000 workers, i.e. very roughly 13 per million. The Peoples Republic of China has a NATIONAL suicide level of 197 per million for men and 80 per million for women. (Overall, and as an example that’s very similar to Sweden and Canada. For men it is similar to the UK.)

    Both of these rates are higher than the rate for Foxconn as reported here. If these were the only suicides at Foxconn then it seems a much safer place to work than the PRC generally – or Canada, Sweden or the UK for that matter.

    I have to tell you (jimkahnw and pofadda), as someone who has experienced suicide within my family, that neither socialism nor capitalism is in any way implicated in these sad events. 13 people were in despair; they killed themselves. Working conditions had only a trivial contribution to make.

Previous post:

Next post:

>